
Last Updated: March 29, 2026 (Price & Content Verified)
Cassiy Johnson gets it: you scroll through YouTube and see oodles of Etsy success stories and a sadness washes over you because you feel like you missed the boat.
But you haven't, she says. You can still make money on Etsy. This year, next year, and beyond.
Print on demand is cheap to start and super low risk.
You can be up and running faster than you can microwave a Hot Pocket. List an item today, get your first sale by tomorrow.
Hmm. Is Cassiy sure about that?
Read on for my POD Roadmap review.
Pros of selling on Etsy:
- Etsy's growing like crazy. They're running ads on TV, at sporting events, just dumping money into the brand. More Etsy shoppers means more eyeballs for you as an Etsy seller.
- Tools like Printify, which is the print-on-demand company Cassiy used to do over $750,000 in sales on Etsy, let you operate like Walmart while working from the couch in your jammies.
- POD is basically ecommerce without manufacturing, inventory, or shipping. Smooth as butter on a hot skillet.
- You can run ads right on Etsy to get sales fast and scale from there.
- Worried about saturation? You can always make designs around trends, news, memes, pop culture, and whatever else people are already paying attention to.
Cons of selling on Etsy:
- Competition, obviously. Etsy has nearly 10 million active sellers. About the time you finally find a winning design, watch, dozens of little knockoffs will sprout overnight.
- Because of this, it takes a ton of time, energy, creativity, and consistency. You can't just fling spaghetti at the wall and hope one noodle pays the mortgage. Just because it's comfy and convenient doesn't mean it's not a real-ass business.
- Paper-thin margins, if you're not careful. Printify takes a healthy bite, which, fair enough. Etsy grabs another 6.5% of each sale. Then you've got software, tools, ads, mockups, photography, and all the other little expenses lining up with their hands out.
- And don't forget: it's Etsy's house, Etsy's rules. If they want to raise fees, they can. If they want to hold your money, they can. If they want to suspend your account, they can do that too.
- Then there's customer service. Just imagine all the dumb questions, the complaints, and waking up to 1-star reviews. Sounds about as fun as parallel parking in front of people.
For Cassiy, the pros of Etsy and print on demand far outweigh the cons.
For me, I'm not so sure.

Cassiy put in at least 20-30 hours a week her first year on Etsy, in addition to working a full-time job.
She profited a little over $60k that year.
Not bad. That means she made roughly $45 an hour in her Etsy business - a hell of a lot more than Chipotle pays you to build burritos behind a sneeze guard.
But still.
With other side hustles, you can make hundreds or even thousands of dollars per hour worked. Maybe not right away, but over time.
More concerning is that Cassiy said her Etsy store got suspended in month two or three, and it took her weeks to get it back.
That right there is what I hate about building a business on someone else's platform.
Especially when that platform belongs to a public company whose whole job is to keep shareholders fat and happy.
You think some rich old board member at Etsy gives a damn if your "World's Okayest Brother" t-shirt gets flagged for fake reviews, your account gets auto-suspended, and your income goes face-down in the yard?
You're adorable. I had no idea you grew up Amish.
Now pile on the weak margins and ruthless copycats and you can see why Etsy's not my thing.
But if you're sold on the model, Cassiy's POD Roadmap course looks like a solid way to learn it.
It costs $799 or four payments of $225.
If you want to build an Etsy print-on-demand business, then yes, I do think it's worth it. I'd give this an 8/10.
Cassiy's great.
I feel like she's the type you could have housesit and your pain pills wouldn't go missing.
Q&A
Q: Do you know anyone who's had success with print on demand and/or Etsy?
A: No. My friend tried it a few months back and said it was awful. Took her an entire day to design and list one shitty coffee mug she knew wouldn't sell. Guess what? It didn't. The thought of repeating that misery hundreds of times to maybe get a few winners that net, what, $7 a sale? Yeah, no thanks. She closed her Etsy store and canceled Printify and Canva a week later.
Q: Cassiy Johnson net worth?
A: You must think I'm Tony Rich and nobody knows it but me. Ask Cassiy, hon. (No, you're right. You should definitely take me to Sense of Humor Court. You'll win, but all you'll get is a Starbucks gift card for an unknown amount and $11 in Kohl's Cash.)
Q: What's her Etsy store name?
A: JollyFamDesigns. Almost 26,000 total sales. But when you go to it, there's a yellow box that says "JollyFamDesigns is currently not selling on Etsy."
Q: How come?
A: Some say Cassiy shut it down because, after it was leaked, it became obvious she got lucky during Covid... and that blatant copyright and trademark violations (from Netflix shows, etc.) contributed to her success.
Q: So does she only make money off her course now?
A: I would hope that she launched a new incognito shop and runs it by the book. That way, she still walks the walk, but who knows.
Q: What's Reddit saying?
A: Nothing good. Reddit's like a gang of teens in black ski masks riding their bikes into Walgreens in broad daylight, smashing up the place, and taking whatever they want. You don't try to be a hero. You just step aside and let 'em do their thing.
Q: Gosh. What if I'm on the fence about POD Roadmap?
A: Test the waters with Cassiy's free Etsy + POD Launch Guide at CassiyJohnson.com. It's a nine-module mini course that covers opening your Etsy store, syncing to Printify, creating your first design, and listing it for sale on Etsy. Then go from there.
Q: Are there any POD Roadmap alternatives I should consider?
A: At the very least, compare and contrast it with the following programs:
- Be A Wolf Biz
- 0-100k System
- The Print Sprint
- Monica Little Coaching
- The Etsy Selling Formula
- Print On Demand Academy 3.0
Q: How do you make money?
A: Local SEO. But like, new and improved with AI. Here's a video on it.